Efficacy and Safety of Deep Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Versus High-Frequency Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation for Major Depressive Disorder: A Systematic Review


In the field of mental health treatment, advancements in non-invasive brain stimulation techniques are continually reshaping the landscape for patients with Major Depressive Disorder (MDD). The latest research, as published in Current Behavioral Neuroscience Reports by Nan Zhang and colleagues, sheds light on an important comparison between two forms of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) technology: Deep TMS (dTMS) and high-frequency repetitive TMS (HF-rTMS). Their systematic review offers exciting insights that could help inform clinical decisions for treating MDD.

Key Findings: The review examined data from two high-quality randomized controlled trials (RCTs), both of which compared the efficacy and safety of Deep TMS and HF-rTMS in adult patients with MDD. The findings highlight a significant advantage for Deep TMS in terms of antidepressant response rates:

  • Response Rates: Deep TMS achieved an overall antidepressant response rate of 60.0%, notably higher than the 41.7% response rate seen in patients receiving HF-rTMS with a figure-8 coil. This nearly 20% difference underscores the enhanced efficacy of Deep TMS, making it a standout option for MDD treatment.
  • Safety and Tolerability: Both Deep TMS and HF-rTMS showed similar rates of adverse events, including headaches, scalp discomfort, and muscle twitching, as well as similar rates of treatment discontinuation. This suggests that while Deep TMS offers superior effectiveness, it maintains a safety profile comparable to HF-rTMS, making it an attractive option from both an efficacy and tolerability standpoint.

Implications for Treatment: These findings are promising for the future of depression therapy. Deep TMS, with its ability to stimulate deeper brain structures, has shown significant advantages in response rates, which could translate to improved outcomes for patients who struggle with traditional antidepressant medications or other non-invasive treatments. While HF-rTMS using the traditional figure-8 coil remains an effective tool, Deep TMS appears to offer enhanced benefits without compromising safety.

For clinicians, these results may serve as a guide when determining the best course of treatment for individuals with MDD, particularly those who may benefit from a more robust response. As the mental health field continues to evolve, the integration of new technologies like Deep TMS into treatment protocols could represent a crucial step forward in addressing treatment-resistant depression.

In summary, Nan Zhang et al.’s systematic review highlights the superior efficacy of Deep TMS compared to HF-rTMS in treating Major Depressive Disorder. With its favorable safety profile and higher antidepressant response rate, Deep TMS stands as a promising, more effective therapeutic option for depression.


"Their entire team is FABULOUS. They have always treated me with dignity and respect. I have watched them with other clients as well and I see their genuine compassion for everyone that walks thru the door. I initially went to them because I moved to CO in late 2017 and they were the first place that had an opening. I needed a psychiatrist to keep me on my Rx. I was surprised when Dr Park spent more than 15 mins going over my past Rx history with me, as has been my experience for many years. Not only did we discuss Rx, he then spent another 45 mins talking to me as a counselor. I had never had a psychiatrist/counselor combo before and was amazed at how effective it is when your Dr hears more about what's going in your life than just the effects of your current Rx. This treatment model is not practiced by someone that doesn't care about his patients. He could offer the basics that most psychiatrists offer and still bill insurance the same amount but he wants his patients to succeed and is invested in their progress. He also doesn't believe in keeping someone in therapy forever. Even if it means less income for him, when you stabilize to the point that you have better things to do than spend 30 mins with him, it's a sign that you may be ready to engage in therapy less often and he will tell you that. Dr Park has been a life and marriage saver for me and he is amazingly efficient. He gets done in 1-2 sessions what would take 6 months for another counselor because he doesn't dance around the issues. To do this, he may be more blunt with you than you might have experienced before and that may be off putting to some. If you are ready to do the hard work to make your life enjoyable again, Dr Park is your man! He also got me hooked up with TMS. If you are someone that has struggled with depression for a long time and taken Rx that hasn't been effective, talk to someone about TMS. It's a game changer. It may sound like hokey fake science. It's not. It works and works fast. THANK YOU!"

– E.M.